[Skip to Content]Privacy Policy
 
Reservations
Guest Reviews

Superb Put-in-Bay Restaurants

Discover a complete Put-in-Bay Ohio guide to the best restaurants and bars, with location and contact information. Here at Put-in-Bay, we have no shortage of variety! From a cheeseburger in the paradise of the north to a fine dining experience, from chicken wings to a juicy steak, you will find what your heart desires from the list of merchants below.
 
Many establishments serve outstanding food during the day, and then turn in to great entertainment hotspots by night. From comedians to nationally known musical acts, you are sure to find excitement and variety at Put-in-Bay!
 

Blue Marlin Bar & Grill

Blue Marlin Bar & Grill
The Put-in-Bay Resort is home to The Blue Marlin Tiki Bar. A tropical themed bar, there is a large pool with a 40 person Jacuzzi. You can swim right up to the bar and try one of our signature frozen tropical cocktails or have your favorite concoctions from our fully stocked bar. Also, there are ample lounge chairs to catch a few rays while at Put-in-Bay. Listen to DJ Billy the Kid and make the most of your time on the Lake Erie Islands. The Blue Marlin Tiki Bar at The Put-in-Bay Resort is the place for both islanders and guests to kick their shoes off and relax.
 
Address: 439 Loraine Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-7427
Website: www.putinbayresort.com

Put-In-Bay Pizza Company

Put-In-Bay Pizza Company
Located within the Put-in-Bay Resort complex, the Put-in-Bay Pizza Company caters to the entire island and specializes in free delivery to guests of the Put-in-Bay Resort and Bay Lodging Resort. An extensive Italian restaurant features thin and thick-crust pizza, strombolis, grinders, and larger-than-life salads. Open late every night and until 3am on weekends. Don't miss out on this PIB favorite!
 
Address: 439 Loraine Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-0504
Website: www.putinbaypizzaco.com
 

Buckeye Tiki Bar

Buckeye Tiki Bar
Located at the Bay Lodging Resort, the Buckeye Tiki Bar is a favored hangout on Saturdays for the island's Ohio State crowd. Daily drink specials draw locals and visitors alike to enjoy the friendly camaraderie of the "Big Top" bartender. Relax poolside by the island's only indoor-outdoor swimming pool as you sip a frosty beverage and root on the Buckeyes!
 
Address: 405 Lakeview Ave, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456   |   Phone: 888-742-7829
Website: www.baylodging.com
 

Mr. Ed's Bar and Grille

Mr. Ed'S Bar and Grille
Mr. Ed's Bar and Grille is the place to be on Put-in-Bay. The food and entertainment at Mr. Ed's rivals that of other establishments. A large breakfast buffet is offered on the weekends including an omelet station. Lunch portions are sizable with hand cut fries. Try their juicy burgers or a massive turkey reuben. While you're here you might as well stay for a while. Mr. Ed's proudly provides the best live entertainment for its patrons. Check out the entertainers page for more info on the upcoming acts at Mr. Ed's Put-in-Bay.
 
Address: 272 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-3101
Website: www.mredsputinbay.com

Boardwalk Restaurant

Boardwalk Restaurant
With stunning views and scrumptious meals, The Boardwalk Restaurant at Put-in-Bay has much to offer. After an extensive addition and remodel, this establishment offers diners many choices in service and food. You can choose to get a bowl of famous Lobster Bisque through the traditional cafeteria-style main level. Or you may opt to sit on the Upper Deck and be served in a warm atmosphere. Whatever your preference, The Boardwalk has something for you.
 
Address: 2 Bayview Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-3695
Website: www.the-boardwalk.com
 

Subway

Subway
Put-in-Bay Subway has you covered when you get hungry at the Bay. Freshly baked bread and fresh ingredients come together to make the sub sandwiches they are famous for. There are also pizzas, wraps and salads made to your specifications. Subway at PIB is open late night to satisfy those after midnight hungers.
 
Address: 272 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-5555
Website: http://www.subway.com
 

Big Mans Burrito Stand

Big Mans Burrito Stand
Big Man's Burrito Stand offers a wide range of Mexican options, from jam-packed steak burritos featuring rice, cheese, lettuce, black beans, sour cream, salsa and other fillings, to the simple pork burrito. There are also vegetarian options for those who don't eat anything that used to have a face on it.
 
Address: 252 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-3278
Website: www.frostys.com

Chicken Patio

Chicken Patio
The Chicken Patio at Put-in-Bay has been serving chicken dinners for since 1952. Half chickens are prepared on a 21 foot charcoal grill and basted with their signature wine sauce. Corn on the cob, potato salad and a dinner roll complete this finger licking meal. Cocktails are available from the outside bar of The Roundhouse. If you get a waft of some delicious food while strolling downtown Put-in-Bay, chances are it's The Chicken Patio. Don't forget the sauce!
 
Address: 60 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-3581
Website: www.chickenpatio.com
 

Boathouse Bar & Grill

Boathouse Bar & Grill
Home of island legend Pat Dailey, The Boathouse Bar and Grill offers hot entertainment and tasty food. The Walleye and Perch sandwiches are so fresh from this eatery they may have been sleeping the waters of Lake Erie the night before! Conveniently located near the Jet-Express, The Boathouse is ready to serve you on your next vacation to Put-in-Bay.
 
Address: 218 Hartford Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-5665
Website: www.theboathousebarandgrill.com

Cameo Pizza

Cameo Pizza
Cameo Pizza at PIB has quickly became a staple of a trip to the Islands. Each day the crust is made from scratch and the famous Cameo blend cheese is prepared daily. Choose from pizzas, sandwiches, wraps and salads. Be sure to try their signature menu items such as the Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza. A ridiculously delicious combination! Late night Cameo Pizza offers pizza by the slice to cure your munchies.
 
Address: 438 Catawba Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 418-285-4444
Website: www.cameopizza.com

Little Galley

Little Galley
Have a cheeseburger in paradise at The Little Galley at Put-in-Bay. Located within The Boardwalk Restaurant, this eatery has a wonderful laid-back atmosphere. Sit out and take in the wonderful views of the Put-in-Bay harbor on the outdoor dining decks. Come and satisfy your big appetite at The Little Galley!
 
Address: 2 Bayview Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-3695
Website: www.the-boardwalk.com
 

Fish Shack

Fish Shack
For the freshest seafood on Put-in-Bay, check out The Fish Shack. Relax on the numerous patios that outline The Boardwalk Restaurant, where this eatery is located. Gaze at the very waters where your delicious Perch and Walleye once swam. This PIB restaurant has the eats ready for the seafood lovers in your group.
 
Address: 2 Bayview Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-3695
Website: www.the-boardwalk.com
 

Frosty Pizza

Frosty Pizza
Frosty Family Pizza has been a Put-in-Bay tradition for over 50 years. They have proudly been welcoming patrons into their establishment, while never requiring a cover charge. Dig in to some of their famous pizza or opt for their sizable subs. While waiting for your meal, play a game of pool on the billiards table. Frosty's at Put-in-Bay is the place for icy cold beer and hot, scrumptious pizza.
 
Address: 252 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-3278
Website: www.frostys.com

Hooligans Tavern

Hooligans Tavern
Hooligans is Put-in-Bay's Original "Irish Pub and a Snug, With Music and Grub." Featuring reuben and corned beef sandwiches, fish & chips, shepherd's pie and other delicious menu items. We also boast a wide variety of Irish Whiskeys and all your favorite spirits. Enjoy any one of our draft beers including, of course, Guinness - all poured in our 20 oz pint glasses! Beautiful inside and out, Hooligans is proud to be your "Getaway at the Bay!"
 
Address: 421 Catawba Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-8000
Website: www.hooliganspib.com
 

The Keys

The Keys
The Keys Complex welcomes you to enjoy four distinct destinations for cocktails and dining, all in one beautiful waterfront location. Lola's Key entices you with gourmet appetizers and an impressive selection of sandwiches and salads. Tortugas Rum Nation offers breakfast, lunch and dinner with an assortment of Caribbean and South Florida Menu Items. Daily entertainment is served with along with the best in Frozen Cocktails and top-shelf RUMS! The Crazy Chicken is our patio grill area where we serve up Jerk Chicken, Smoked Brisket, Smoked Half Chicken and some great St. Louis Ribs. Last but not least, come for a cocktail and enjoy the best in Sushi upstairs at Nagoya.
 
Address: 227 Bayview Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-5397
Website: www.thekeyspib.com
 

Mossbacks Island Bar & Grill

Mossbacks Island Bar & Grill
Mossback's Grill has great food and views for the PIB traveler. Offering a wide selection of signature burgers, sandwiches and dinner options, Mossback's is the place to eat. The décor is warm and inviting and they strive to make your meal memorable. So whether you're looking for a great lunch with friends or a romantic dinner, Mossback's at Put-in-Bay is for you!
 
Address: 371 Catawba Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-8888
Website: http://mossbacksatputinbay.com/

Upper Deck Restaurant

Upper Deck Restaurant
The Upper Deck at The Boardwalk Restaurant is the place for great service and live entertainment. Lake Erie Perch and Walleye from local sources ensure the quality and taste of your meal. Relax with a glass of wine while gazing at the Put-in-Bay harbor from the impressive large windows that surrounds The Upper Deck.
 
Address: 2 Bayview Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-3695
Website: www.the-boardwalk.com
 

Pasquale's

Pasquale's
Pasquales Café overlooking DeRivera Park in downtown Put-in-Bay has wonderful breakfast and lunch menu items. Stop by for breakfast and try a breakfast sandwich, our famous biscuits and gravy or the well known T-bone and eggs special. Lunch options include sandwiches, paninis and pizzas made to your liking. Try Pasquale's on your next trip to PIB, your taste buds will thank you!
 
Address: 234 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-8600
Website: http://www.pasqualescafe.com/
 

Put-In-Bay Brewing Company

Put-In-Bay Brewing Company
The Put-in-Bay Brewing Company on Catawabe Ave. is a great place for friends to meet up and grab some food. A great selection of appetizers, juicy burgers and famous pizza make this eatery a favorite stop for many diners. Match up your meal with a beer brewed in-house. Each year The Brewery offers three to five different beer varieties.
 
Address: 441 Catawba Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-4677
Website: www.putinbaybrewery.com

Village Bakery

Village Bakery
Smells of freshly brewed coffee and pies permeate from The Village Bakery at Put-in-Bay. Orders can be placed for specially made cakes and pies to celebrate birthdays, weddings and many other occasions. Stop by for lunch and try a tasty fresh made sandwich or wrap. Also, soft serve Edys ice cream is sure to cool you down during the hot summer days at Put-in-Bay.
 
Address: Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-5351
Website: NO WEBSITE
 

The Goat Soup & Whiskey

The Goat Soup & Whiskey
Get away from the action of downtown Put-in-Bay and enjoy the relaxing atmosphere of The Goat Soup and Whiskey. There are several soups that are prepared daily for your delight. Sandwiches, salads and soups round out the lunch options. A fully stocked bar is ready to mix up your favorite libations. You can enjoy the breeze from the open air terrace, or sit inside in the large sitting area.
 
Address: Catawba Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-4628
Website: www.soupandwhiskey.com

The Roundhouse Bar

The Roundhouse Bar
An island tradition and favorite for over 130 years, The Round House Bar is a Put-in-Bay must see. Here you will find wonderful live entertainment throughout the week. Here is the home of Island favorite Mike "Mad Dog" Adams, and he can be seen frequently on the weekends throughout the summer season. Enjoy the views of DeRivera Park and downtown Put-in-Bay from the front porch. Don't miss out at this gem of the Lake Erie Islands, and make the most of your Put-in-Bay adventure.
 
Address: 60 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-2323
Website: www.theroundhousebar.com
 

Joe's Bar & Restaurant

Joe's Bar & Restaurant
Joe's Bar at PIB is the spot for both locals and guests to get away from the hustle and bustle of downtown Put-in-Bay. Have one of Joe's signature drinks or put back your favorite mixer. Watch the golf carts whiz by as you sit on the quaint front porch. Because at Joe's "Beer is Food!"
 
Address: Meechen Rd., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-2716
Website: www.joesbarpib.com
 

Reel Bar

Reel Bar
Serving up the best burger on the bay is the newly renovated Tony's Garage. Located on Catawba Avenue, across from the Island General Store, this bar & grill offers a huge selection of draft beer and cocktails, not to mention killer burgers, hot dogs, wings and more! Live entertainment by the Reese Daily band, karaoke, disco parties and great drink specials, make this one hot spot not to be missed!
 
Address: 60 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456   |   Phone: 419-285-1318
Website: www.reelbar.com